Skip to main content
Someone reading a letter at a kitchen table

How to Appeal a CHC Decision

A refusal is not the end of the road. There are three stages: local resolution with the ICB, an Independent Review Panel through NHS England, and the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman. Each has its own time limit and its own limits on what it can look at.

Last updated: November 2026

The Short Answer

If your relative has been refused NHS Continuing Healthcare, there are three stages available to challenge it, in order. First, local resolution with the Integrated Care Board (ICB) that made the decision. If that does not resolve it, an Independent Review Panel arranged by NHS England. If you remain unhappy with how the whole process was handled, the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman.

Each stage has its own time limit, and each one can only look at certain things. None of them exists to re-run the clinical assessment from scratch, so the strongest appeals are the ones that say exactly what went wrong with the original decision, not just that the family disagrees with the outcome.

The Care Home Family Handbook

The Care Home Family Handbook

The handbook's NHS funding section walks you through the Checklist, all 12 domains, Fast Track and how to challenge a refusal, with ready-to-send letters.

See what's inside

£47, 14-day money back guarantee

Stage 1: Local Resolution

Every ICB must have a published local resolution process. You have six months from the date you are given the eligibility decision to ask for a review. This six month figure comes from NHS England's Local Resolution Best Practice Guidance, which ICBs follow to meet the National Framework's requirement that they publish a fair, transparent process with clear timescales. Check the wording in your own decision letter, since the exact deadline is set by the ICB's own process rather than written into the National Framework as a number.

The ICB is expected to deal with a review request within three months of receiving it, and to aim to give you an outcome in that time. That is an expectation rather than a guarantee.

The process usually runs in two steps. First, an informal discussion, often by phone, where the ICB explains how it reached the decision and you can raise what you think was missed or misunderstood. If that does not resolve things, a formal Local Resolution meeting follows, with a senior ICB representative from outside the original multidisciplinary team involved, so the review is not simply the same people confirming their own decision.

Be specific about what you are challenging: which domain scores you disagree with, what evidence supports a different score, and why the original assessment got it wrong. A general complaint that your relative needs more care is far weaker than a domain by domain argument.

Stage 2: Independent Review Panel

If local resolution does not change the decision, you can ask NHS England for an Independent Review (IR). NHS England will not normally accept an IR application until the ICB has completed local resolution, so this stage comes after, not instead of, stage one. The exception is where going through local resolution would cause undue delay, in which case NHS England can agree to go straight to an IR.

  • ✓Once you request the application form, you have six weeks to return it for the application to proceed
  • ✓NHS England says the process typically takes three to six months from there
  • ✓New evidence is only allowed if it would have been reasonable for the ICB to have obtained it already but did not. This is also your last opportunity to add anything, nothing further can be introduced later in the process
  • ✓The panel is independent of the ICB that made the original decision

Stage 3: The Ombudsman

Once the NHS process has run its course, usually local resolution followed by an Independent Review, you can complain to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman (PHSO) if you remain unhappy with how your case was handled. The Ombudsman is independent of the NHS entirely.

You normally need to bring the complaint within 12 months of the final response, though the Ombudsman has some discretion to look at a complaint made later if there is good reason for the delay.

The Ombudsman looks at whether the process was handled properly, not at scoring the Decision Support Tool domains again. If it finds fault, it can recommend a remedy, including financial redress.

What the Independent Review Panel Cannot Look At

NHS England is explicit that the Independent Review process cannot consider:

  • •the content of the eligibility criteria itself
  • •the type or location of any care package offered
  • •the treatment or services received
  • •an ICB's refusal to carry out a full assessment after a negative Checklist
  • •the calculation of any redress payment

Those go through the NHS complaints procedure instead. See our guide to complaining about a care home for how that route works.

Sources

This guide covers England. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have separate continuing care arrangements.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to request a review after a CHC refusal?
Six months from the date you are given the eligibility decision. This comes from NHS England's own Local Resolution Best Practice Guidance, not a fixed deadline in the National Framework itself, so check the decision letter for how your ICB has worded it. Stage 1: Local resolution.
How long does local resolution take?
ICBs are expected to deal with a review request within three months of receiving it, and to aim to provide an outcome within that time. It is an expectation, not a guarantee, so ask for a date in writing if it is running long. Stage 1: Local resolution.
Can I go straight to the Independent Review Panel?
Not normally. NHS England will not accept an application for an Independent Review until the ICB has completed local resolution, unless there are exceptional circumstances, such as local resolution causing undue delay. Stage 2: Independent Review Panel.
What can the Independent Review Panel not do?
It cannot look at the content of the eligibility criteria itself, the type or location of any care package offered, the treatment or services received, an ICB's refusal to carry out a full assessment after a negative Checklist, or the calculation of any redress payment. Those go through the NHS complaints procedure instead. Stage 2: Independent Review Panel.
Can I introduce new evidence at the Independent Review stage?
Only if it would have been reasonable to expect the ICB to have obtained and considered it when it made the original decision, but it failed to. This is also your last chance to add information: nothing further can be introduced after this stage.
What does the Ombudsman do?
The Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman looks at how your case was handled after you have been through the NHS process (normally local resolution and the Independent Review Panel). It does not re-score the Decision Support Tool domains. You normally need to complain within 12 months of the final response, though the Ombudsman has some discretion to look at a complaint made later. Stage 3: The Ombudsman.
The Care Home Family Handbook

The Care Home Family Handbook

The handbook's NHS funding section walks you through the Checklist, all 12 domains, Fast Track and how to challenge a refusal, with ready-to-send letters.

See what's inside

£47, 14-day money back guarantee

New

Have a question this guide didn't answer?

Ask in our Community Forum and get a real answer from someone who's been through it.

Share what's on your mind